Recognizing a concern is only the beginning. What happens next depends, in part, on whether people believe it is safe to raise it.
A nurse questions a staffing assignment. A new graduate asks for help with an unfamiliar procedure. A faculty member challenges a decision about student progression.
Each has something to contribute. Each also faces a decision: What might happen if I speak up?
Will the concern receive thoughtful consideration? Will the question be treated as a sign of inexperience? Will disagreement affect future assignments, opportunities, or relationships?
The answers help shape psychological safety—and whether important information becomes part of the conversation.
In the Story…
In Forced ERRORS, Nicole enters an unfamiliar ICU and begins learning how the unit operates. Clinical routines are only part of that learning. She also encounters different approaches to leadership, support, and expectations.
Some interactions make it easier to ask questions and seek guidance. Others leave her uncertain about how concerns will be received.
Annie’s experience, explored in the previous post, raises the same issue. Her objection to repeated overtime involves more than staffing. It also reveals the interpersonal risk of challenging someone with authority over her work.
Together, these experiences invite a question that extends beyond the novel:
What are people learning about speaking up in this environment?
Beyond the Story…
What Is Psychological Safety?
Psychological safety is a shared belief that a team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking. It allows people to ask questions, acknowledge uncertainty, discuss mistakes, and offer a different perspective without expecting humiliation or punishment for doing so. Edmondson’s foundational research associated psychological safety with the behaviors through which teams learn.
In everyday work, those risks can seem small:
Asking someone to explain an instruction.
Admitting that a procedure is unfamiliar.
Pointing out a possible error.
Questioning an established practice.
Disagreeing with a respected colleague.
Yet each requires someone to make their uncertainty or disagreement visible. AHRQ identifies the ability to raise ideas, questions, concerns, and mistakes without fear of humiliation or punishment as central to psychological safety.
Safety and Accountability Belong Together
Psychological safety does not remove professional standards. Nurses remain accountable for their practice. Faculty remain responsible for sound teaching, fair assessment, and academic integrity. Leaders still need to address performance concerns.
The practical question is how those expectations are maintained.
A new graduate who acknowledges uncertainty needs appropriate guidance and supervision. A faculty member who identifies a weakness in an assessment process deserves a fair hearing. A nurse who reports an error needs the event examined carefully, with attention to both individual actions and system conditions.
Difficult conversations remain necessary. People need to be able to participate in them without being demeaned.
People Learn From the Response
An invitation to speak up has limited value if the response makes people regret accepting it.
Consider what colleagues may learn when:
A question receives an impatient or dismissive answer.
A concern is acknowledged but repeatedly receives no follow-up.
Someone who disagrees is described as difficult.
A mistake is discussed primarily in terms of personal blame.
A leader asks for input after the decision has effectively been made.
These are examples to examine, rather than proof that every difficult interaction reflects an unsafe culture. Patterns, context, and what happens afterward matter.
Leaders also have practical opportunities to support participation: acknowledge their own uncertainty, ask for perspectives they may be missing, thank people for identifying problems, and explain what will happen next. AHRQ’s guidance offers concrete language for encouraging questions, requests for help, and improvement ideas.
What Silence Can Hide
A quiet team is not necessarily a team without concerns.
Edmondson’s early hospital research found that units with stronger ratings of nurse manager coaching and working relationships had higher detected medication-error rates. Her interpretation highlighted an important complication: detected errors reflect both what occurs and what people are willing to disclose. The study could not establish actual error rates independently of detection and reporting.
For leaders, the implication is straightforward: a low number of reports does not, by itself, establish that care is safe.
The same question can be useful in education. When nobody questions a curriculum decision, reports a concern about an assessment, or challenges an established practice, leaders should consider whether the silence reflects agreement—or reluctance to participate.
Where Incivility Enters the Conversation
Psychological safety and incivility are related, but they describe different aspects of a work environment. Psychological safety concerns the anticipated consequences of speaking up. Incivility concerns behavior that falls short of expectations for respectful interaction.
That distinction offers a useful way to examine everyday conduct. An eye-roll, public dismissal, or pattern of exclusion may affect more than the immediate interaction. It may also influence whether someone contributes the next time.
This is where the conversation moves naturally from clinical practice into nursing education. At the bedside and around the faculty table, professional expertise is most useful when people can bring it into the discussion.
Before asking why people remain silent, it is worth examining what happens when they speak.
Leadership Takeaway
“Leaders strengthen psychological safety when they maintain clear standards and respond to questions, concerns, and disagreement with respect, curiosity, and follow through.”
Questions to Engage Learners
What interactions help a new nurse or faculty member determine whether it is safe to ask questions or disagree?
How can a leader address a performance concern while preserving the person’s willingness to ask for help or report a future mistake?
When a team raises few concerns, what additional information would help distinguish agreement from reluctance to speak?
What might staff or faculty learn when their concerns are acknowledged but receive no follow-up?
Think of an opportunity to invite a perspective that is often missing from a discussion. What could you do to make that invitation meaningful?
Evidence Behind the Story
Explore the Story
Severson, Annette. (2025). Forced ERRORS.
Annie’s concerns about repeated overtime and Nicole’s experiences entering an unfamiliar ICU provide opportunities to examine professional voice, leadership responses, and the perceived risks of speaking up. Consider how these interactions influence what nurses are willing to question, report, or ask—and what their colleagues learn by watching.
Explore Forced ERRORS and its companion Faculty Guide.
Research and Practice Resources
Edmondson, A. C. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383.
Introduces team psychological safety and examines its relationship with learning behaviors, including seeking feedback, discussing mistakes, and asking for help.
Edmondson, A. C. (1996). Learning from mistakes is easier said than done: Group and organizational influences on the detection and correction of human error. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 32(1), 5–28.
Examines medication-error detection in hospital units and explains why reported errors must be interpreted in the context of the working environment and willingness to disclose mistakes.
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2025). Psychological safety.
Provides a healthcare-focused explanation of psychological safety and resources for supporting open discussion of concerns and improvement opportunities.
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2018). Creating psychological safety in teams: Handout.
Offers practical examples of language that encourages team members to ask for help, identify obstacles, and contribute ideas.
Ready to take the discussion further?
The Forced ERRORS Faculty Guide extends the novel into a structured learning experience with chapter-specific leadership and patient safety themes, discussion prompts, competency connections, and tools for engaging learners.